Same formula, different era

The average specification written by a non-technical person was, in Tom’s experience, about as precise as the average recipe written by someone who had never cooked for anyone other than themselves. It contained all the right ingredients in approximately the right proportions but omitted crucial details that the writer took for granted because they were obvious to them and invisible to anyone else. “Season to taste” is a perfectly useful instruction for someone who knows what the dish is supposed to taste like. For a machine that has no taste buds, it is meaningless. ...

~Scott Werner in Warranty Void If Regenerated

If insanity is doing the same thing over and over again and expecting different results, then how does it feel trying to get a specific result generated by a similar workflow tweaked over and over again?

On a plane, above the clouds, I live in a world of dichotomies, struggling to find good movies, yet refusing to use WiFi because where else can you escape the world below. So I watched a docu-reality show about Hong Kong street food stalls running their same shop for decades, listened to a podcast that mentioned you can't learn English pronunciation by speaking the same sentence over again and again...

And I thought about what else people do in life over and over again. Things like buying the same Toto ticket (maybe with different numbers) every week, and expecting to win. Writing the same thought leadership pieces on LinkedIn (recycled from other thought leaders), and expecting higher follower counts and/or career progression. Meeting up with the same cohort of people at conferences, and expecting innovation.

At what point does habit turn into addiction, agreeableness blurs into mundane, brainstorming dampens into groupthink?

I am reminded of one of my environmental psychology lessons from a dozen years ago (mentioned before), how, to get people to do good behaviour, e.g. recycling, it doesn't work well by just feeding people information (about how recycling is good), but rather, people will just do it because they see their neighbours putting out the recycling bin (crowd behaviour). The corollary to that, is that once people get into the habit of recycling, it can be hard to persuade them that reducing and/or reusing is much better, and indeed, these waste minimization techniques are harder for people to 'see' and mimic from their neighbours.

Passive nudging was a compelling idea, but active boosting is where it gets dangerous. It is one thing if everyone decides to do their own thing (whether by influence or not), but a completely different game when institutions start supporting it, and give it an aura of authority.

Having been to three workshops on three different continents in the past month, and hearing how organizations are providing subscriptions to their employees or students, effectively subsidies, makes me feel nauseous. Of course not everyone uses them, you don't have to use them, but going from encouraging its use (nudge) to providing a subscription (boost) has given it a sense of legitimacy, sigh.

Now people can try things over and over again, but at what cost?


For months, I've been trying to reconcile my feelings on where my career is going, indeed, where my field is heading. As I document my feelings and grapple with the foundations of trust, my financial savvyness considers a career change to hardware or something, maybe robotics, to hedge some bets. Because even farming/agriculture (which I'm doing a project on currently) isn't sheltered anymore, if the sci-fi article linked at the top is anything to go by.

In some sense, I knew I just needed a break, and step outside the box for a bit to see the box itself.

Around late September, early October, I gave myself just that, some leave from work. Well, there was a local aerospace conference I had to attend (my first panel invite, woohoo!) in between, but it was at least within country, and I didn't have to prepare much besides some answers to pre-canned questions. For most of the week, I didn't realize it (until looking back), but apparently I might have given out some good food for thought for the next generation.

Those ideas didn't come solely by myself (it was a 'team' effort), but it sure felt cozy being able to articulate it properly.

Something that kept getting brought up at that conference, was the 'dual-use' nature of aerospace technology. Indeed, I passed protestors as I entered the venue, and the number of police officers guarding the compound seemed crazy (side note: I attended this same conference back in 2018? as a student, and the contrast is stark). Working in Earth Observation, you'd be naive to not know that the peaceful, civilian/humanitarian, environmental component is dwarfed by the military part of the sector.

This duality could be said for many other technologies in general, and I was curious about how it could be resolved.

As the hours went on, I hear about how space has transitioned from government-led to commercial-led, ... Things like how competition is no longer as pressing an issue as coordination (to avoid space junk hitting each other). It all sounded quite familiar, common sense even, the result of a technology or field maturing.

And with this maturity, there are things to consider like regulation, safety, continuity. I heard the quote 'leaving space for space', because we do want a sustainable ecosystem that allows the next generation to participate in. Looking at this adjacent high-tech field, and seeing local startup companies think about refueling satellites in space, solar-powered flight, it felt that there was room for integrity, for hope.

Yet as I commiserated with academics panicking about the government's insane push towards commercialization ('strategy without implementation is useless'), I hear how culture eats strategy for breakfast. The key to resolving the dual-use nature of tech was never by having better tech, refuelable satellites could well be used for spying, solar planes can still carry weapon payloads. You could go even further back and see (this revisionist history) of how after the bronze age, easier access to iron democratized violence.

So yes, the problem is culture.


Now one would think that creating a culture of integrity means arguing by principle, but I would reductio ad absurdum that by saying when there are too many principles to debate over, you cannot win the war without winning every battle. Starting from the why makes sense for simple cases, it breaks down for complex situations because humans can't fit everything in their head.

So we go for the simple, limit the verbosity, and purposely constrain the messaging.

I think of the Buddha's tales, traditional folklore tellers, they all tell compelling stories, stories that resonate with the audience. Sure the fundamental principles don't change, but the story always has to adapt with the times, to be understood by people young or old.

Those stories could be referencing the past, or it might show a potential future. They need to show what happens, how it happens, the meaning behind it is to be figured out by the listener.

That figuring out, we need more of.